What’s in it for the owner?
The honest answer: real value, but only under O3. The owner ends richer taking O3 than selling — yet that is exactly the structure the operator cannot afford at base yields.
What the owner has at year 10
Terminal wealth is the owner’s total position at year 10 under each choice. Three choices happen without the deal — hold the shell, sell now, or self-finish with a standard manager — and three take a ZaCoastal deal.
Greater Cairo
Per unit, EGP nominal, 10-year term.
North Coast (Sahel)
Per unit, EGP nominal, 10-year term.
Red Sea
Per unit, EGP nominal, 10-year term.
| Market | Hold | Sell now | Self-finish | O1 | O2 | O3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cairo | 8.49M | 9.19M | 7.68M | 7.71M | — | 9.82M |
| North Coast | 12.97M | 14.04M | 12.44M | 12.60M | — | 14.86M |
| Red Sea | 5.90M | 6.38M | 5.79M | 5.84M | — | 7.05M |
The wealth-maximising fallback is sell now in every market. Self-finishing with a manager is the closest like-for-like (keep-and-rent) comparator, but it is the lowest of all the choices. O3 is the top of the table in every market, and O1 is near the bottom. O2 is not reported in the v3 source.
O3 gives the owner real surplus — the operator just can’t afford it
Against the best fallback (selling), O3 leaves the owner +0.6–1.0M better off per unit. Against the same yardstick, the operator loses −0.19–−0.38M at base yields. Both things are true at once.
| Market | O3 owner surplus (vs sell) | O3 operator NPV (base) |
|---|---|---|
| Cairo | +0.64M | -0.37M |
| North Coast | +0.82M | -0.38M |
| Red Sea | +0.67M | -0.19M |
Owner surplus is measured against the wealth-maximising fallback — selling now. The mid-tier surplus is +0.64–+0.82M; the premium tier runs +0.72–+1.04M, which is where the +0.6–1.0M headline range comes from. Per unit, EGP nominal, 10-year term.
The owner’s best outcome (O3) is the operator’s worst. For the operator to break even at base yields it would need to take roughly 45–87% of NOI — far above the assumed 30% — or the owner would need to accept a lower terminal wealth than selling. There is no share at which both are better off at base yields except a thin Red Sea O1 band. See Results.
Owner surplus = owner terminal wealth under the deal minus owner terminal wealth under the best no-deal fallback (selling, in every market). It is not the owner’s cash return; it is the net position at year 10. The operator NPV is the discounted operator cash flow at the hurdle, negative when the operator is paid below the hurdle rate. The two measures move in opposite directions because the owner and operator are dividing the same NOI.