Methodology

How the model is built, and how it is checked

A single deterministic cash-flow model, per unit, EGP nominal, over a 10-year term, run for three structures across three markets and two fit-out tiers. The six tests below all pass.

The three structures

The operator (ZaCoastal) finishes and furnishes a core-and-shell unit and operates it as a rental under 100% management. The owner keeps the unit but has no personal use; the fit-out is repaid in one of three ways:

  • O1 — 100% cash upfront. The owner pays the full cost plus markup in cash; the revenue share starts from first operation.
  • O2 — partial cash. The owner pays part of the cost plus markup in cash; the rest is recouped from operating income; the revenue share starts once recouped.
  • O3 — 100% from operating income. The owner pays nothing upfront; the operator recoups the full fit-out from operating income; the share starts once recouped.

The model walks through three phases: fit-out (capex and overrun risk), recoup (NOI is applied to the operator’s balance first), then split (NOI is shared between operator and owner).

Key parameters (base case)

Base-case parameters used throughout the model.
ParameterSymbolBase valueMeaning
Cash markupm15%Markup charged on the cash portion of fit-out.
Deferral markupm_def25%Markup on the deferred (recouped) portion; the report argues it must be fixed at signing.
Cash sharep50%Fraction of fit-out paid in cash upfront (O2).
Cash-markup multiplierk0.5In O2 the cash-part markup is m × k.
Recoup rater100%Share of NOI applied to recoup during the recoup phase.
Operator NOI shares_op30%Share of NOI after recoup (base case).
Term—10 yrModel horizon.
Hurdle—T-bill + 8ptDiscount rate for operator NPV est.
VAT on short stays—0 / 14%Modelled both ways; unresolved legal question.

Exact definitions live in za_model_v3.py; this page summarises the six tests, not the source code.

The six tests

All six pass. They are the reason the numbers in the report can be trusted as internally consistent, even though the inputs they run on are still unverified.

Six passing model tests and what each one checks.
TestWhat it verifiesResult
Ledger conservationGross = VAT + opex + refurbishment + operator take + owner receipt, in all options / geographies / VAT settings.PASS
Closed-form recoupOperator total take = min(10·N, B0) + s·(10·N − B0) with constant NOI.PASS
Limiting casesZero share / zero markup loses; huge O1 markup wins; zero revenue → loss.PASS
MonotonicityNPV up in revenue and share; owner surplus down in share; overrun hits the operator only.PASS
O2 reduces to O1/O3O2(p=1, k=1) = O1; O2(p=0) = O3.PASS
Hand calculationO1 with m=0, s=0, no overhead, no tax → operator NPV = 0.PASS

What passing these tests does — and does not — prove

Internal consistency is not external accuracy

The six tests prove the arithmetic is consistent: every EGP is accounted for, the recoup formula is closed-form correct, the limits behave, and the results move the right way when inputs move. They do not prove the inputs are right. The realised gross yield, fit-out cost and hurdle are still unverified calibrations — and the realised yield is the single largest driver of every result.

Treat this as a model, not a forecast. The full list of unverified inputs and the unresolved legal items is on the assumptions & risks page; the headline findings and complete tables are in the full report.